Synopsis
Rose is one of three daughters of a rich merchant who always brings gifts for his girls from the market. One day Rose asks for the seed of a blue bean, but he fails to find one for her. She lets out a sigh in resignation, and her sigh attracts the Sigh, a mysterious being that brings the seed she desired to the merchant.
But every debt has to be paid, and every gift has a price, and the Sigh returns a year later to take the merchant’s daughter to a secret and distant palace.
Review
I picked this one up the other day when I went to a signing and talk by Tom Gauld in Leeds, I’d not come across it before, but it was apparently released last November. It’s not so much a graphic novel like her other works, it’s more of an illustrated short story, but one I thought would be perfect to read during the Once Upon a Time Reading Challenge.
I’m not sure if it’s based on an existing fairy tale, but it does have a very traditional feel as if it could be. The story follows Rose in to Ah, the Sigh’s distant world. Where she lives a comfortable life, a visit home, causes her to look at her new life with new eyes.
She ends up discovering something wonderful, then almost as quickly losing it. Driven by guilt she repeatedly sells herself into slavery, trying to make amends for her mistake.
It was a lovely little story, with a typically strong ‘message’ as you’d expect from a fairy story, and some wonderful accompanying artwork, but if I’m honest, I think it could have done with a little more meat-on-the-bones, to make it a really satisfying read.
Rating
[xrrgroup][xrr label="Characters:" rating="4/6" group="s1" ] [xrr label="Plot:" rating="4/6" group="s1"] [xrr label="Writing:" rating="4/6" group="s1"] [xrr label="Artwork:" rating="5.5/6" group="s1"] [xrr label="Just One More Page:" rating="5/6" group="s1"] [xrr label="Overall:" overall=true group="s1" ][/xrrgroup]

![Supermarket by Brian Wood and Kristian Donaldson [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Supermarket-by-Brian-Wood-and-Kristian-Donaldson-271x146.jpg)














Is this a new book by her? I haven’t seen this one before, and I love Satrapi!
I have never heard of this book before either. I will have to go look it up. Great review!
The premise sounds so strange and different. It does sound like a fairytale that I might like though.
There’s much more too it was well, but I didn’t want to spoil the plot too much
I’m intrigued…it sounds a bit like “East of the Sun and West of the Moon,” maybe, but with some variations. May need to check it out!
Not come across that one, I’ll have to take a look…
[...] for a a really great read, and a good way to start of the Once Upon a Time challenge, (I know I reviewed The Sigh, the other day, but this was actually my first book for the challenge, I am that lax in getting my [...]
I like the concept of this story- and am in the mood for a good illustrated read right now. This would be a new-to-me author too, which I am on the prowl for!
Ooh, you need to read her graphic novel memoir, Perspolis, about her childhood in Iran. Fantastic stuff!
Ah, I’m glad you mentioned this one; I’ve enjoyed her others quite a bit and will be happily to suss out a copy of this one. (Embroideries left me wanting a “bit more”, as you’ve said about this one, but I still enjoyed it, too.)