Increase the Effectiveness of Your Next Review Request
aka: A Better Way to Contact Me

Like most book bloggers I get my fair share of authors, publishers and publicists making use of my contact form to try to get me to read/promote their latest book.
By far the most common request I get is some variation on the standard ‘form’ letter, now there’s nothing wrong with this, but unless
you’re Suzanne Collins or Scholastic offering me the an ARC of Catching Fire – hey I can always hope!
– then it isn’t going to stand out from the rest, so, if you are not in that fortunate position then a different approach is needed.
So, I thought might be a good idea to take a quick look at what makes some requests more successful than others.
Simply because of way I was contacted, I recently accepted two books that normally I would have declined, the first was a self-published work and the second was from a small publisher.
- If you are a self-publisher, then unfortunately, you are going to have to work harder than most. It’s probably not your fault and I don’t dismiss self-published works out-of-hand, but there are too many people who can self-publish that shouldn’t, and end up with poorly edited, un-proof-read, books, and I have unfortunately ended up with my fair share. So if you want me to consider your book, and you self publish, then you could do worse than follow the example of a recent publicist.
Who, first of all sent a polite email commenting on my blog and reading tastes, told me a little about the book and the author and then pointed me towards a well designed informative website, where I cold get more information, and ended by asking if I might be interested in talking further.
I was impressed by the site, and intrigued enough by the book’s plot that I followed this up with an email expressing some interest and asking for more information. To which I again received a polite and individual reply, the end result: I agreed to read the book.
- Another example: this time again from a publicist but this time from a small press publisher. Once again, I received a polite friendly initial email, from someone who had obviously read my blog and knew a little about the kind of books I liked to read.Unfortunately, this particular book didn’t tempt me. However, I still ended up accepting a book from them. Why? When I replied to decline the offer, I received a lovely response and ended up having a great conversation with the guy. The result? A week or so later a book dropped on my doorstep.
What do both of these have in common? They each took the time to tailor their pitch to me personally, had actually looked at my blog, and then didn’t just send a form letter, because of this I gave them the requests the attention the extra effort this deserved.
Will this work every time? Let’s be honest, no it’s not. I’m still going to have to be interested enough by your book to take it on and review it, but if I had just received a form email, then I probably wouldn’t have agreed to take either.
To open this up to everybody else; has the way you’ve been contacted, ever persuaded you to review a book you normally wouldn’t? Or have you had requests that stand out in of memory even if do didn’t end up reviewing the book. Share your experiences in the comments.


















Yes! The type of pitch definitely influences whether or not I will accept to review a book. Several months ago, I, along with several other book bloggers, received a pitch from a publisher. It was the best pitch email I’d ever received. The publicist had clearly viewed my blog and took the time to peruse several of the pages, not just the main page. The pitch was for a book I normally wouldn’t have accepted, but because this individual took the time to customize a pitch for me, I agreed to review the book and will be doing so later this month.
When I receive a generic pitch email (Dear Book Blogger, Dear Editor, Dear Reviewer) I’m less likely to consider reviewing the book. I understand that publicists are very busy people and can’t send individual emails all of the time, but it’s really the first impression that counts with me. If you can take time to get to know me, my blog, and my reading tastes, I’m more prone to take the time to consider reviewing your book.
Jenn’s Bookshelf´s last blog ..Teaser Tuesday, July 14
So you mean when I talk into one end of the can you haven’t been hearing it over there all this time?! LOL..
This is a great post Darren! All of this is so true. Honestly, half of the time when I get a request that’s just your basic form letter, it ends up getting deleted. Unless it really catches me right away. But I actually get excited about reading someone’s book when they’ve taken the time to actually write ME something.
Chris´s last blog ..Bad Bloggers 7/13/09
I don’t think great communication has ever convinced me to accept a book I wasn’t initially interested in, but form letters definitely make me less likely to. I too, prefer a personal touch.
Jeane´s last blog ..bookmark giveaway!
This is so true! (Yes, very useful comment, I know.) I’ve decided to revamp my notes for authors and publicists so it’s a little clearer after receiving an email from someone who had clearly not bothered to look through my blog. I must admit, it did make me a little angry. It wouldn’t have taken more than five minutes (if that long) to see I wasn’t a good candidate for the book in question. I know people tend to be busy, but surely, surely five minutes’ worth of research to determine whether or not this blogger is someone interested in your book in the first place should be part of the service publicists are offering…
*clears throat* Sorry. Bee up my bonnet and all that. I do love this post, though, and I’m sorely tempted to link to it and go “See? This is what catches my interest! Only said far better than I could.”)
Shanra´s last blog ..A post!