
The snow came down so thickly, it formed fragile snowballs in the air that tumbled and melted as soon as they landed on the horses lined up along the dock.
This one was my Christmas present to myself, and I’m so glad I snapped up the limited edition version, as I feel it captures the ‘mood’ of the book much better that the normal UK version, and certainly the US cover.
Mau, is returning the traditional coming of age ritual of his island nation. Meanwhile a young girl distant cousin of the King is making her way to join her father who has been posted to one of the South Pelagic islands.
A Tsunami changes both of their lives forever, everyone from Mau’s nation, has been killed by the wave, and Daphne is the only known survivor from the Sweet Judy, the ship transporting her across the oceans.
Together, they must first learn to understand each other, both in language and experiences, and then as others start to arrive, they must rebuild the Nation, and help shape it’s future.
Pratchett comments in his afterword, that the book contains “some thinking” and it most certainly does.
There are different ways to eat people, girl, and you are clever, oh yes, clever enough to know it. And sometimes the people don’t realise it has happened until they hear the belch!
This is a hugely philosophical book, and Pratchett touches, on tradition, nationhood, beliefs, customs, religion and death, throughout the book, so anyone expecting an out and out comedy should be aware, that some work from the reader is going to be required to fully appreciate the book, that’s not to say there is no humour, there is and plenty of it.
”Move, I said!”
They obeyed as wise men do when a woman puts her foot down…
But it is also, balanced with incredibly serious moments, the section where Mau, is clearing the island of it’s dead and sending them on their way, is gut-wrenchingly well observed, and I defy even the hardiest of souls not to be touched while reading it.
It takes a writer of Pratchett’s skill and experience to get this balance right, and I’d say it is one of the best things he has written. Period. Some may be funnier, some may be more entertaining, some may be more exciting, some may even contain ‘some thinking’. But as a package. this is stand out, excellent. and the first addition to my 2009 best reads list.
Mau and Daphne are wonderful main characters, and really grow as the story goes on, Mau is more of a man. by the end of this story than probably anybody on his island previously, despite what rituals they may have successfully competed, and without giving the end away, Daphne also grows in to exactly the person she needs to be.
“You are very clever,” said the man shyly. “I would like to eat your brains, one day.”
For some reason the books of etiquette that Daphne’s grandmother had forced on her didn’t quite deal with this.
This is easily my favourite Pratchett for many a book and I even get the feeling that this one will only get better with subsequent readings.
Other Reviews to Consider:
[rating:96/100]
They saw that the perfect world was a journey, not a place.

![Invisibility by Andrea Cremer and David Levithan [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Invisibility-by-Andrea-Cremer-and-David-Levithan-313x146.jpg)
![His Dark Materials by Phillip Pullman [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2004/06/His-Dark-Materials-by-Phillip-Pullman-313x146.jpg)
![Supermarket by Brian Wood and Kristian Donaldson [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Supermarket-by-Brian-Wood-and-Kristian-Donaldson-271x146.jpg)
![Airborn by Kenneth Oppel [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Airborn-by-Kenneth-Oppel-313x146.jpg)

![Girls and Monsters by Anne Michaud [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Girls-and-Monsters-by-Anne-Michaud-299x146.jpg)
![Planesrunner by Ian McDonald [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Planesrunner-by-Ian-McDonald-251x146.jpg)
![Dare You To by Katie Mcgarry [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Dare-You-To-by-Katie-Mcgarry-313x146.jpg)
![Pushing the Limits by Katie Mcgarry [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Pushing-the-Limits-by-Katie-McGarry-210x146.jpg)
![The Split Worlds #1: Between Two Thorns by Emma Newman [Review]](/bookshelf/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/The-Split-Words-Between-Two-Thorns-by-Emma-Newman-255x146.jpg)



















Great review! And what a gorgeous looking cover, I like it much better then the other one.
Joanne´s last blog post: FYI – Review Questionnaire
I really liked your review. I’ve tried to read Pratchett in the past but gave up. You sound like you really understand this author. Where do you suggest a newbie should start? Can you read this novel without reading any other book before it?
I’m a middle school librarian and we have quite a few of his books on the shelves. In fact, I think I have this one, but I know that there are some that are in a series. Any insight you could give me would be greatly appreciated!!
Hi Staci!
I’d say this was the perfect first book to read, as it is a complete stand-alone from his Discworld books, and as I say, it is one of the best things he has written.
Bravo! I couldn’t agree with you more. There’s so much deep thought put into this book and it was such a touching, humorous, well written piece of work! And I totally agree with you on the cover. That one is so much better than the one here in the US…honestly, Pratchett gets some really crappy US covers.
Chris´s last blog post: Doh!
Definitely one of the best he’s ever written. The more I think about it, the more I love it. And it will grow on me even more with re-readings, I bet.
I like that cover a lot, but I actually also like the regular UK one. The US one, not so much.
Nymeth´s last blog post: Watchmen by Alan Moore and David Gibbons
Do you know what I think it is with the covers… I think his UK publishers understand whatever the book, his readership comprises everyone from 8 to 80(+) and so designs it’s covers accordingly, the US cover is obviously aimed at attracting only a younger market and assumes that the interested older readers will pick it up anyway.
I, of course, could be completely wrong in that assumption though!
Thanks for your help. I’m going to try to read this book this year sometime.
Staci´s last blog post: Teaser Tuesdays
I agree about the cover, I think it express the meaning of the book much more.
Valentina´s last blog post: Q & A with Inbali Iserles
I loved this one too. He definitely strikes a perfect balance between humor and philosophy. The last quote about eating brains was my favorite!
[...] Reviews: Adventures in Reading, Bart’s Bookshelf, Birdbrain(ed) Book Blog, Book Clutter, Boston Bibliophile, Fluttering Butterflies, In the Shadow [...]
[...] Nation by Terry Pratchett | My Review [...]